Shalom! A question for Jews.
Let's say that my Saviour was just a Dionysian/Mithraism construct, but that I lived a godly life (to the best of my knowledge). When I die(d), would I be resurrected and or go to ';heaven';, as per Jewish theology? Or would I stay in Sheol?Jewish question. Is there a good afterlife for Xtians, if Xrist was a false messiah?
Righteous Gentiles have a place in the World to Come, and are deemed ';righteous'; by the 7 laws given to Noah after the destruction of the world by flood. The ';no false gods'; clause, as you point out, could be a deal breaker. We don't really judge that, whether or not someone is written in the Book of Life is up to God to judge whether their idea is false or not. Even then, moderately so-so righteous may have the chance to go to Gehinom (Yiddish Gehenna), which is a temporary place of rectification of that soul. It takes a certain amount of righteousness to get to ';hell'; or Gehinom. One must merit it prior to going to Paradise. If one doesn't there are several options. (The very righteous don't spend much time if any at all there, but no one spends eternity there). Sheol is an earlier term than Gehinom appearing in Genesis and refers to a common grave or holding place for both Jews and Gentiles, all humanity until the resurrection of the dead when Mashiach comes.
According to oral tradition there are a number of other ways to rectify a soul, e.g. gilgul or coming back to earth to finish learning whatever was left undone, or by being lost - a lost soul wandering the earth like a ghost for a while. This is a more severe punishment than ';hell'; or Gehinom, but it is needed for recalcitrant types.
Both Jew and Gentile will experience the resurrection when Mashiach comes. The Hebrew word Olam Ha-Ba (';the world to come';) is used for both the messianic age and the afterlife, Gan (Garden) of Eden. The world to come is the final destination for humanity to look forward to. A Mishnah passage says, ';This world is like a lobby before the Olam Ha-Ba. Prepare yourself in the lobby so that you may enter the banquet hall.'; The tractate Moed Katan teaches, ';This world is only like a hotel. The world to come is like a home.'; RaMChaL says it's like a entry hall, and Olam Haba is the room you want to go to.
Everything in the world and in the celestial realms is for our rectification and spiritual advancement to get to Olam Haba. The goal is to get everyone up to speed eventually. The totally evil, however, will be destroyed at the end of time as will all evil. It will have served its purpose in guiding the righteous to the truth and away from evil.
Easiest to Read Source for how Olam Haba works (A Jewish Theory of Everything): Derech Hashem by Moses Chaim Luzzatto outlines this and the footnotes will give Talmudic references in Oral Torah for these ideas.Jewish question. Is there a good afterlife for Xtians, if Xrist was a false messiah?
Judaism says 'all righteous souls shall have a share in the world to come'. It doesn't matter which faith a person follows. If you live your life in a moral, meaningful way, you will reach 'gan eden' or 'garden of eden'.
'Sheol' refers to a type of purgatory where a soul resides for up to one year, for 'purification'. From what I understand, most people will spend a bit of time there, and only the truly and totally righteous will go straight to 'gan eden'.
http://www.thekosherfiles.webs.com
We believe that all people who seek to do good have a place in the World to Come. Even though we believe Christians to be misguided, if they're trying to be good people, that's all Judaism has ever asked of anybody.
There is a place in the world to come for all good people, regardless of their religion.
At the time of death, everyone is separated to one side of the gulf, or the other. Do not go to the wrong side.
Either way, the most prosperous up there are Jewish. (e.g. Abraham and Messiah)
He is not false....yes we will live eternally!!
Monday, February 8, 2010
Christians, is the ';rapture theory'; preparing the church world to accept the false messiah as the true Christ
I am so completely confused about what is TRUTH and what is not I have no idea! I wish I knew what was Biblicley correct and what is not!Christians, is the ';rapture theory'; preparing the church world to accept the false messiah as the true Christ
Jesus is the true Messiah. The rapture is not a theory. Why are we who are saved being caught up to meet Jesus in the air. The Rapture is not Jesus's second coming.Christians, is the ';rapture theory'; preparing the church world to accept the false messiah as the true Christ
What do you mean by ';Christians';???
hmm.
OUT
only certain christians are stupid enough to believe in the rapture, the rest are just ordinarily so....
Then what was Jesus talking about in Matthew and Luke.
Mat 24:38 For as in the days that were before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day that Noe entered into the ark,
Mat 24:39 And knew not until the flood came, and took them all away; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.
Mat 24:40 Then shall two be in the field; the one shall be taken, and the other left.
Mat 24:41 Two [women shall be] grinding at the mill; the one shall be taken, and the other left.
Mat 24:42 Watch therefore: for ye know not what hour your Lord doth come.
Mat 24:43 But know this, that if the goodman of the house had known in what watch the thief would come, he would have watched, and would not have suffered his house to be broken up.
Mat 24:44 Therefore be ye also ready: for in such an hour as ye think not the Son of man cometh.
1 Thes 4:17 Then we which are alive [and] remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever be with the Lord.
Where are we going if this is talking about the second coming? If this is at the end of the tribulation period chances are we will not be alive. If you take the mark of the beast you not be going up to meet Jesus when he comes and if you dont take the mark you will be put to death.
1Th 5:9 For God hath not appointed us to wrath, but to obtain salvation by our Lord Jesus Christ,
This verse says that we will avoid the wrath that God is going to pour out on the earth.
Either way I dont see how it would make people believe the false profit. I would think just the opposite. People who are expecting for Jesus to come back to earth would fall for the false messiah more easily because they are expecting Jesus to come back and set up His Kingdom. The Holy spirit would help those who are saved dissern between good and evil.hair highlights
Jesus is the true Messiah. The rapture is not a theory. Why are we who are saved being caught up to meet Jesus in the air. The Rapture is not Jesus's second coming.Christians, is the ';rapture theory'; preparing the church world to accept the false messiah as the true Christ
What do you mean by ';Christians';???
hmm.
OUT
only certain christians are stupid enough to believe in the rapture, the rest are just ordinarily so....
Then what was Jesus talking about in Matthew and Luke.
Mat 24:38 For as in the days that were before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day that Noe entered into the ark,
Mat 24:39 And knew not until the flood came, and took them all away; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.
Mat 24:40 Then shall two be in the field; the one shall be taken, and the other left.
Mat 24:41 Two [women shall be] grinding at the mill; the one shall be taken, and the other left.
Mat 24:42 Watch therefore: for ye know not what hour your Lord doth come.
Mat 24:43 But know this, that if the goodman of the house had known in what watch the thief would come, he would have watched, and would not have suffered his house to be broken up.
Mat 24:44 Therefore be ye also ready: for in such an hour as ye think not the Son of man cometh.
1 Thes 4:17 Then we which are alive [and] remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever be with the Lord.
Where are we going if this is talking about the second coming? If this is at the end of the tribulation period chances are we will not be alive. If you take the mark of the beast you not be going up to meet Jesus when he comes and if you dont take the mark you will be put to death.
1Th 5:9 For God hath not appointed us to wrath, but to obtain salvation by our Lord Jesus Christ,
This verse says that we will avoid the wrath that God is going to pour out on the earth.
Either way I dont see how it would make people believe the false profit. I would think just the opposite. People who are expecting for Jesus to come back to earth would fall for the false messiah more easily because they are expecting Jesus to come back and set up His Kingdom. The Holy spirit would help those who are saved dissern between good and evil.
If the Jews killed Jesus then doesn't that make him a false messiah?
In Deuteronomy 13 it gives the guidelines of what makes one a prophet. It then goes on to state how a false prophet should be handled by the Jewish community.
In Acts 10:39, it blames the death of Jesus on the Jews
';And we are witnesses of all things which he did both in the land of the Jews, and in Jerusalem; whom they slew and hung on a tree'; (Acts 10:39)
If the Jews killed Jesus then that makes him a false prophet basically because he failed the guidelines of being a prophet based on Deuteronomy 13. The Jews would have not had a reason to kill Jesus if this was the case. Which means the pharisees were correct about Jesus.
So is Jesus a false prophet if the Jewish people killed him?If the Jews killed Jesus then doesn't that make him a false messiah?
Jesus is a false messiah because he didn't fulfill the messianic prophecies.
Fulfilling the messianic prophecies is the only way to know someone is the Jewish messiah. If he didn't do it... he wasn't it. That's all the reason anyone needs.
-- and I mean the actual prophecies, not the ones Christians mistake as prophecies about virin births and ressurections. These are not part of the Jewish messianic prophecies.If the Jews killed Jesus then doesn't that make him a false messiah?
The jews killed just about all of the prophets God sent them throughout history. Jesus' death was prophesied by Daniel:
Da 9:26 And after threescore and two weeks shall Messiah be cut off, but not for himself: and the people of the prince that shall come shall destroy the city and the sanctuary; and the end thereof shall be with a flood, and unto the end of the war desolations are determined.
Jesus fulfilled over 600 prophecies about the Messiah.
When Jesus was alive nobody really liked him. He had ideas that most people disliked. It wasn't till after he was dead that people made a story about him being the son of god, and his followers did a great p.r. job, and then people started liking him. So yeah, when they killed him he was considered a false prophet, and was hated.
Very interesting question...This is why christian scholars are at pain to try and convince everyone regarding the ressurection. You made the point very clear from your reference, but they try and argue that he rose again therefore he wasnt killed.
So, effectively, if the ressurection is disproved then christianity is also disproved.
Yes according to the Jews and those who follow the OT but not to the Christians who ignore that and wrote their own book NT about how he was the messiah.
It just depends on what you give credit to more. The book that came first or the new book that justified Jesus and made the Jews look bad?
Isaiah 53:1, 3 – “Who has believed our message? To whom will the Lord reveal His saving power? He was despised and rejected – a man of sorrows, acquainted with bitterest grief. We turned our backs on Him and looked the other way when He went by. He was despised, and we did not care.”
- The Messianic prophecy of Isaiah 53 foretells of Jesus' rejection by his own people. The fact that it did happen doesn't discredit Him. In fact, it is yet more proof that He was the Messiah.
Jesus came to die for the sins of man knowing the Jews would kill him. Prophecy fulfilled.
Jesus wasn't killed because they believed him to be a false prophet. He was killed because they didn't believe he was who he said he was, the son of God.
From what I understand, he failed to fulfill many aspects of the ';prophecy.';
Which is only a problem if you are unable to re-write the prophecy in later revisions of the book.
Deuteronomy 13 talks about how to evaluate a prophet....it does not prophecy of the Messiah.....Isaiah 53 foretells of the Messiah....
Isaiah 53:3 ';He is despised and rejected by men...';
Just because the jews had a hand in Jesus being killed, doesn't make him a false prophet, jews are human just like the rest of us, they are not (';the deciders'; LOL) on who should be what.
the priests at the time of Jesus death were crooks who paid to be priests and report negative activities to Rome !!! It was Herod's temple
financd by Rome !!! The priests were murderers !!! John the Baptist father was a Levite priest and was MURDERED IN THE TEMPLE !!! And the family went to live with the Essenes [my theory] and that is probably where John was raised !!!
http://www.eadshome.com/Jesuslessons.htm
when you figure out the difference between messiah and prophet, come back again
he was a rabbi, a jew
showing a real ugly side here
hideous really
NO....NO....NO...
pontious pilate also made that wicked decision..
No
It just means that they didn't accept Him for who He was.
This act by Jews was also a fulfillment of prophecy.
your friend
1) yes he was a false prophet/messiah
2) the Jews did not kill him, the Romans did.
Exactly
nope because his death was for told long before his death
BOO YEAH!
When you consider Isaiah 53, and the prophecies in Daniel, that the Messiah would die for us, the fact that the Jewish leadership had Jesus executed by Roman means, only proves that Jesus is who He claimed to be - especially since he was resurrected after wards.
Think about this for a moment: If Jesus had NOT been raised from the dead, then what happened to the body? (i.e., ';Who Moved The Stone?';)
Did the disciples move the body just to perpetrate a fraud? Why would Peter allow himself to be crucified UPSIDE DOWN when he could simply have avoided the entire thing by just recanting. And yet Peter was SO convinced that Jesus was resurrected, that He was willing to face persecution and even a horrible and painful death, than to deny what he considered to be true. And there have been MANY martyrs both before as well as since. Read ';Fox's Book of Martyrs'; or go to ';The Voice Of The Martyrs'; web site for additional examples.
So, if the disciples didn't remove the body, and of course the Romans wouldn't have, then did the Jewish leaders? If they did, they could have squelched this entire movement just by producing the body! And yet, they didn't!
So, what happened to the body that early Sunday morning, three days after the crucifixion?
Jesus prophesied that He would be crucified, and that He would rise again, and He did. So how is THAT being a false prophet?
You have some serious questions you need to face and respond to! There WILL be a test on this material, so be prepared!
In Acts 10:39, it blames the death of Jesus on the Jews
';And we are witnesses of all things which he did both in the land of the Jews, and in Jerusalem; whom they slew and hung on a tree'; (Acts 10:39)
If the Jews killed Jesus then that makes him a false prophet basically because he failed the guidelines of being a prophet based on Deuteronomy 13. The Jews would have not had a reason to kill Jesus if this was the case. Which means the pharisees were correct about Jesus.
So is Jesus a false prophet if the Jewish people killed him?If the Jews killed Jesus then doesn't that make him a false messiah?
Jesus is a false messiah because he didn't fulfill the messianic prophecies.
Fulfilling the messianic prophecies is the only way to know someone is the Jewish messiah. If he didn't do it... he wasn't it. That's all the reason anyone needs.
-- and I mean the actual prophecies, not the ones Christians mistake as prophecies about virin births and ressurections. These are not part of the Jewish messianic prophecies.If the Jews killed Jesus then doesn't that make him a false messiah?
The jews killed just about all of the prophets God sent them throughout history. Jesus' death was prophesied by Daniel:
Da 9:26 And after threescore and two weeks shall Messiah be cut off, but not for himself: and the people of the prince that shall come shall destroy the city and the sanctuary; and the end thereof shall be with a flood, and unto the end of the war desolations are determined.
Jesus fulfilled over 600 prophecies about the Messiah.
When Jesus was alive nobody really liked him. He had ideas that most people disliked. It wasn't till after he was dead that people made a story about him being the son of god, and his followers did a great p.r. job, and then people started liking him. So yeah, when they killed him he was considered a false prophet, and was hated.
Very interesting question...This is why christian scholars are at pain to try and convince everyone regarding the ressurection. You made the point very clear from your reference, but they try and argue that he rose again therefore he wasnt killed.
So, effectively, if the ressurection is disproved then christianity is also disproved.
Yes according to the Jews and those who follow the OT but not to the Christians who ignore that and wrote their own book NT about how he was the messiah.
It just depends on what you give credit to more. The book that came first or the new book that justified Jesus and made the Jews look bad?
Isaiah 53:1, 3 – “Who has believed our message? To whom will the Lord reveal His saving power? He was despised and rejected – a man of sorrows, acquainted with bitterest grief. We turned our backs on Him and looked the other way when He went by. He was despised, and we did not care.”
- The Messianic prophecy of Isaiah 53 foretells of Jesus' rejection by his own people. The fact that it did happen doesn't discredit Him. In fact, it is yet more proof that He was the Messiah.
Jesus came to die for the sins of man knowing the Jews would kill him. Prophecy fulfilled.
Jesus wasn't killed because they believed him to be a false prophet. He was killed because they didn't believe he was who he said he was, the son of God.
From what I understand, he failed to fulfill many aspects of the ';prophecy.';
Which is only a problem if you are unable to re-write the prophecy in later revisions of the book.
Deuteronomy 13 talks about how to evaluate a prophet....it does not prophecy of the Messiah.....Isaiah 53 foretells of the Messiah....
Isaiah 53:3 ';He is despised and rejected by men...';
Just because the jews had a hand in Jesus being killed, doesn't make him a false prophet, jews are human just like the rest of us, they are not (';the deciders'; LOL) on who should be what.
the priests at the time of Jesus death were crooks who paid to be priests and report negative activities to Rome !!! It was Herod's temple
financd by Rome !!! The priests were murderers !!! John the Baptist father was a Levite priest and was MURDERED IN THE TEMPLE !!! And the family went to live with the Essenes [my theory] and that is probably where John was raised !!!
http://www.eadshome.com/Jesuslessons.htm
when you figure out the difference between messiah and prophet, come back again
he was a rabbi, a jew
showing a real ugly side here
hideous really
NO....NO....NO...
pontious pilate also made that wicked decision..
No
It just means that they didn't accept Him for who He was.
This act by Jews was also a fulfillment of prophecy.
your friend
1) yes he was a false prophet/messiah
2) the Jews did not kill him, the Romans did.
Exactly
nope because his death was for told long before his death
BOO YEAH!
When you consider Isaiah 53, and the prophecies in Daniel, that the Messiah would die for us, the fact that the Jewish leadership had Jesus executed by Roman means, only proves that Jesus is who He claimed to be - especially since he was resurrected after wards.
Think about this for a moment: If Jesus had NOT been raised from the dead, then what happened to the body? (i.e., ';Who Moved The Stone?';)
Did the disciples move the body just to perpetrate a fraud? Why would Peter allow himself to be crucified UPSIDE DOWN when he could simply have avoided the entire thing by just recanting. And yet Peter was SO convinced that Jesus was resurrected, that He was willing to face persecution and even a horrible and painful death, than to deny what he considered to be true. And there have been MANY martyrs both before as well as since. Read ';Fox's Book of Martyrs'; or go to ';The Voice Of The Martyrs'; web site for additional examples.
So, if the disciples didn't remove the body, and of course the Romans wouldn't have, then did the Jewish leaders? If they did, they could have squelched this entire movement just by producing the body! And yet, they didn't!
So, what happened to the body that early Sunday morning, three days after the crucifixion?
Jesus prophesied that He would be crucified, and that He would rise again, and He did. So how is THAT being a false prophet?
You have some serious questions you need to face and respond to! There WILL be a test on this material, so be prepared!
Jews how can God lift his name up with a false messiah?
Does he love Jesus or something? I mean Yahweh is not with Allah or the hindus or any other god, that name or Jehovah is not in their bible, but he stands by Christianity with a messiah, and has it as the #1 religion. Do you think God is blind, or do you think he looks like a fool?, to stand by a false messiah as a living God and do nothing but make his name a lie across the earth? Is he dead?Jews how can God lift his name up with a false messiah?
response - how about NOT asking on the Jewish sabbath?
G-d loves everyone and everyone gets there. Unlike the elitist Xtian religious beliefs. Jesus didn't meet the requirements for the Jews. Go blame Paul for adding more than a mega dose of paganism into the mix and mucking things up so you can't tell what Jesus actually might have been - a good teacher.
Not a prophet. Not the Jewish Messiah.
Divine savior - not a Jewish belief
taking on the sins of others - not what G-d said
being G-d but human - nope, G-d said He wouldn't
divine/human sacrifice - nope - G-d rejects thatJews how can God lift his name up with a false messiah?
no he isn't dead, but you have to consider:
for as many bad christians there as many bad(atheists, muslims, etc. etc.)
secondly, false christianity is the beast talked about in revelations. therefore false christianity is the most harmful thing to real christianity, but is actually quite easily defeated by god(or real christians who have his spirit).
lastly, god saved noah because there was no hope for humanity if what was happening was alowed to continue, he sent jesus because if things had been allowed to continue the way they were it would not have been good.
and now...
if he does nothing about the way things are right now it would not be good.
He doesn't need to. The Messianic Prophecies in the Tanakh make it absolutely clear that Jesus was NOT HaMosiach.
Only because of willful ignorance and false interpretations and mistranslations do Christians ignore this fact, and if there is a deity who holds to the value of free will, then such a deity has to yield their right to Christian's rejections of the actual messianic prophecies in favor of Christianity's falsehoods.
Your religion seems complicated
check out pastafarianism
God didn't spread his name all over the world with Christianity, people did. And how in the world do you know what God is doing or what he's standing by?
Who would have done something?
It's pretty hard for nonexistent beings to do things.
I don't know about all that noise, but Satan certainly is cool.
Oh, I so absolutely agree. And may God strike me dead if I'm telling the truth.
What? God is not capable of striking one non-believer dead? Why doesn't God do something like that would prove to every one the trinity is real?
Islam has gone all over the world, too. In case you hadn't noticed. If they were worshiping the wrong God, don't you think the real God would have made it known unequivocally?
Edit: No, you're not quite comprehending. The question is why is the ';logic'; you're using only applicable to Christianity? You seem to be saying, if Christ was false, then God would have done something to denounce him. But why isn't that same logic applicable to all other religions? If they are false, shouldn't God being doing something about it?
response - how about NOT asking on the Jewish sabbath?
G-d loves everyone and everyone gets there. Unlike the elitist Xtian religious beliefs. Jesus didn't meet the requirements for the Jews. Go blame Paul for adding more than a mega dose of paganism into the mix and mucking things up so you can't tell what Jesus actually might have been - a good teacher.
Not a prophet. Not the Jewish Messiah.
Divine savior - not a Jewish belief
taking on the sins of others - not what G-d said
being G-d but human - nope, G-d said He wouldn't
divine/human sacrifice - nope - G-d rejects thatJews how can God lift his name up with a false messiah?
no he isn't dead, but you have to consider:
for as many bad christians there as many bad(atheists, muslims, etc. etc.)
secondly, false christianity is the beast talked about in revelations. therefore false christianity is the most harmful thing to real christianity, but is actually quite easily defeated by god(or real christians who have his spirit).
lastly, god saved noah because there was no hope for humanity if what was happening was alowed to continue, he sent jesus because if things had been allowed to continue the way they were it would not have been good.
and now...
if he does nothing about the way things are right now it would not be good.
He doesn't need to. The Messianic Prophecies in the Tanakh make it absolutely clear that Jesus was NOT HaMosiach.
Only because of willful ignorance and false interpretations and mistranslations do Christians ignore this fact, and if there is a deity who holds to the value of free will, then such a deity has to yield their right to Christian's rejections of the actual messianic prophecies in favor of Christianity's falsehoods.
Your religion seems complicated
check out pastafarianism
God didn't spread his name all over the world with Christianity, people did. And how in the world do you know what God is doing or what he's standing by?
Who would have done something?
It's pretty hard for nonexistent beings to do things.
I don't know about all that noise, but Satan certainly is cool.
Oh, I so absolutely agree. And may God strike me dead if I'm telling the truth.
What? God is not capable of striking one non-believer dead? Why doesn't God do something like that would prove to every one the trinity is real?
Islam has gone all over the world, too. In case you hadn't noticed. If they were worshiping the wrong God, don't you think the real God would have made it known unequivocally?
Edit: No, you're not quite comprehending. The question is why is the ';logic'; you're using only applicable to Christianity? You seem to be saying, if Christ was false, then God would have done something to denounce him. But why isn't that same logic applicable to all other religions? If they are false, shouldn't God being doing something about it?
Will their ever be an established answer concerning how the false messiah Jesus died?
In Acts 10:39 the writer of this book states that Jesus was hanged on a tree and killed by the Jews.
In Acts 10:39 it states :
';And we are witnesses of all things which he did both in the land of the Jews, and in Jerusalem; whom they slew and hanged on a tree:'; (Acts 10';39)
That being in consideration if one reads Matthew 27:21-27 it states that Pontius Pilate killed Jesus and that it was the Romans' fault.
The CROSS scene being the most accepted ;
two basic contradictions; In Acts 10:39
1. It states the Jews killed Jesus opposed to Matthew's claim about the Romans killing Jesus.
2. It states that Jesus was hanged on a tree opposed to Matthew's claim that he was crucified by Pontius.
Show which one was it?Will their ever be an established answer concerning how the false messiah Jesus died?
The Jews had Christ crucified by Pilot on a wooden cross. (Wood comes from trees)Will their ever be an established answer concerning how the false messiah Jesus died?
The Romans did the actual dirty work of hanging Christ on the tree, but it was at the insistence of the Jewish leaders, whose position in the political scheme of things was threatened by Jesus. By the way, the tree, or torture stake that Jesus was hanged on is not referred to as a cross in the Bible. Mainstream Christendom came up with that one all on their own.
We all are responsible for the crucifixion of Jesus not just the Jews and Romans. A cross was made from wood that comes from a tree. Thus the reference to being hung on a tree. Pontius Pilate washed his hands and said I find no fault, but the Jews demanded that Jesus be crucified so Pontius not wanting a riot ordered his men to crucify Jesus and the Jews accepted responsibility. Satisfied now?
No, they don't contradict each other. Each of the accounts make it clear that though the Jews were the ones who wanted Jesus crucified, it was the Romans who actually made it happen. That means both were at fault.
And ';hanged on a tree'; is actually another way of saying ';crucified.';
The answer's right there in plain sight.
@';In Acts 10:39
1. It states the Jews killed Jesus opposed to Matthew's claim about the Romans killing Jesus.
2. It states that Jesus was hanged on a tree opposed to Matthew's claim that he was crucified by Pontius.';
You are missing the point:
His death is more important than the exact way He died.It was on a cross...arms extended or over His head.
His death [THAT HAPPENED] saved our {believers} lives, from the wrath of His Father in Heaven.
No one else can CLAIM THIS!
has it never occured to you that the cross and tree are the same thing?
Sides Jesus laid down His life....no one took it from Him John 10:17-18
And if you are gonna throw the baby out with the bath water....that's pretty pathetic man.
...I'm not sure what ';translation'; of Scripture you are referring to... Consider getting a copy of the Hebrew Text and the Greek Lexicon for a better understand... (your understanding is seriously flawed).
what would a cross be made out of ?? Was it steel ?? Maybe concrete ?? Ohhhhhh, I know, it was FAKE wood !!! geesh..... and He was NOT the fake Messiah.... But, it will be told and shown to all some day...... go in peace..... God bless
Why to do you hate religion? Why can't you just say, I don't believe in god, and leave it at that.
Why not just leave us alone?
Why you got to shove your ideology down our throats?
Jesus was crucified by his hanging on a tree. Pontius had the opportunity to stop the crucification, but he didn't.
Its a mute point. The fact is that Jesus was crucified in payment for our sins.
Since the Romans had crucufied several thousand people I would imagine they had a pretty proficient way of crucifying people.
ya know all I could see in your question, was where you stated ';false';, so what actually is your point here? God Bless and have mercy
Gee, how totally unbiased. Are you asking or telling?
Go read the Scriptures again and get your story straight.
Hung on a tree = wooden cross.
They made the cross from trees and hung Him from it. They didn't have electric saws and lathes 2,000 years ago...
Peace,
AAD
Start over from the beginning and read slower. It may help with your comprehension.
Put down the gun. Have you not noticed that your water bullet cannot kill us believers.
For nowadays it will not be possible, because the gospels are very much confused, very much contradictory.
In the future when logic and reason will be more developed and with the help of the computers,
scholars will find a definite truth and they will all agree.
I think the truth will be towards :
Mainly the Romans punished him to penalty death for their reasons. Not because Romans were pressed by Jews to do that.
Some of these reasons were same by coinsidence with those of some Jews.
@ Cody the conservative : Your objection to the asker is invalide. If you love religion, spontaniously you hate atheism.
So, why you hate atheism ? Why don't you lieve atheists alone to criticise religion ?
Besides don't you think the academic wars have their place in internet ? If you don't like critics on your religion, just don't read these critics. Lieve other people to do ! No problem. You want to make problem because the critics are damaging the lies, not the truth.
actually the bible says the chief priests killed jesus and conspired together.
but they insisted the romans take the blame to keep themselves unspotted.
in the end he was accused for blasphemy, not as the romans thought it was for treason. so the conspiracy led jesus to pilate. who saw that nothing was wrong legally. the fact is there were by far many jews that thought he was teh saviour in fact the entire world knew of jesus as the coming king otherwise the three wise men would not have shown up at his birth with gifts.
the bible is indeed very limiting in knowledge and truth, and christian fathers and leaders have altered much of the text to be what it was not.
as for individual testimony no one ever gets it correct and often ones own perspective will lead to a different assumption. i dont think anyone innocent of a less than perfect testimony.
jesus did die by crucifixion, there is no doubt about that. the romans kept better records than the jews, whether jesus died on a tree or with a bar strapped to his arms is debateable.
the experience with pilate was a deception, among all the leaders, pilate was later called a saint by the byzantines and in teh catholic church he was declared innocent. so at least these things agree.
In Acts 10:39 it states :
';And we are witnesses of all things which he did both in the land of the Jews, and in Jerusalem; whom they slew and hanged on a tree:'; (Acts 10';39)
That being in consideration if one reads Matthew 27:21-27 it states that Pontius Pilate killed Jesus and that it was the Romans' fault.
The CROSS scene being the most accepted ;
two basic contradictions; In Acts 10:39
1. It states the Jews killed Jesus opposed to Matthew's claim about the Romans killing Jesus.
2. It states that Jesus was hanged on a tree opposed to Matthew's claim that he was crucified by Pontius.
Show which one was it?Will their ever be an established answer concerning how the false messiah Jesus died?
The Jews had Christ crucified by Pilot on a wooden cross. (Wood comes from trees)Will their ever be an established answer concerning how the false messiah Jesus died?
The Romans did the actual dirty work of hanging Christ on the tree, but it was at the insistence of the Jewish leaders, whose position in the political scheme of things was threatened by Jesus. By the way, the tree, or torture stake that Jesus was hanged on is not referred to as a cross in the Bible. Mainstream Christendom came up with that one all on their own.
We all are responsible for the crucifixion of Jesus not just the Jews and Romans. A cross was made from wood that comes from a tree. Thus the reference to being hung on a tree. Pontius Pilate washed his hands and said I find no fault, but the Jews demanded that Jesus be crucified so Pontius not wanting a riot ordered his men to crucify Jesus and the Jews accepted responsibility. Satisfied now?
No, they don't contradict each other. Each of the accounts make it clear that though the Jews were the ones who wanted Jesus crucified, it was the Romans who actually made it happen. That means both were at fault.
And ';hanged on a tree'; is actually another way of saying ';crucified.';
The answer's right there in plain sight.
@';In Acts 10:39
1. It states the Jews killed Jesus opposed to Matthew's claim about the Romans killing Jesus.
2. It states that Jesus was hanged on a tree opposed to Matthew's claim that he was crucified by Pontius.';
You are missing the point:
His death is more important than the exact way He died.It was on a cross...arms extended or over His head.
His death [THAT HAPPENED] saved our {believers} lives, from the wrath of His Father in Heaven.
No one else can CLAIM THIS!
has it never occured to you that the cross and tree are the same thing?
Sides Jesus laid down His life....no one took it from Him John 10:17-18
And if you are gonna throw the baby out with the bath water....that's pretty pathetic man.
...I'm not sure what ';translation'; of Scripture you are referring to... Consider getting a copy of the Hebrew Text and the Greek Lexicon for a better understand... (your understanding is seriously flawed).
what would a cross be made out of ?? Was it steel ?? Maybe concrete ?? Ohhhhhh, I know, it was FAKE wood !!! geesh..... and He was NOT the fake Messiah.... But, it will be told and shown to all some day...... go in peace..... God bless
Why to do you hate religion? Why can't you just say, I don't believe in god, and leave it at that.
Why not just leave us alone?
Why you got to shove your ideology down our throats?
Jesus was crucified by his hanging on a tree. Pontius had the opportunity to stop the crucification, but he didn't.
Its a mute point. The fact is that Jesus was crucified in payment for our sins.
Since the Romans had crucufied several thousand people I would imagine they had a pretty proficient way of crucifying people.
ya know all I could see in your question, was where you stated ';false';, so what actually is your point here? God Bless and have mercy
Gee, how totally unbiased. Are you asking or telling?
Go read the Scriptures again and get your story straight.
Hung on a tree = wooden cross.
They made the cross from trees and hung Him from it. They didn't have electric saws and lathes 2,000 years ago...
Peace,
AAD
Start over from the beginning and read slower. It may help with your comprehension.
Put down the gun. Have you not noticed that your water bullet cannot kill us believers.
For nowadays it will not be possible, because the gospels are very much confused, very much contradictory.
In the future when logic and reason will be more developed and with the help of the computers,
scholars will find a definite truth and they will all agree.
I think the truth will be towards :
Mainly the Romans punished him to penalty death for their reasons. Not because Romans were pressed by Jews to do that.
Some of these reasons were same by coinsidence with those of some Jews.
@ Cody the conservative : Your objection to the asker is invalide. If you love religion, spontaniously you hate atheism.
So, why you hate atheism ? Why don't you lieve atheists alone to criticise religion ?
Besides don't you think the academic wars have their place in internet ? If you don't like critics on your religion, just don't read these critics. Lieve other people to do ! No problem. You want to make problem because the critics are damaging the lies, not the truth.
actually the bible says the chief priests killed jesus and conspired together.
but they insisted the romans take the blame to keep themselves unspotted.
in the end he was accused for blasphemy, not as the romans thought it was for treason. so the conspiracy led jesus to pilate. who saw that nothing was wrong legally. the fact is there were by far many jews that thought he was teh saviour in fact the entire world knew of jesus as the coming king otherwise the three wise men would not have shown up at his birth with gifts.
the bible is indeed very limiting in knowledge and truth, and christian fathers and leaders have altered much of the text to be what it was not.
as for individual testimony no one ever gets it correct and often ones own perspective will lead to a different assumption. i dont think anyone innocent of a less than perfect testimony.
jesus did die by crucifixion, there is no doubt about that. the romans kept better records than the jews, whether jesus died on a tree or with a bar strapped to his arms is debateable.
the experience with pilate was a deception, among all the leaders, pilate was later called a saint by the byzantines and in teh catholic church he was declared innocent. so at least these things agree.
Jews and Muslims will you be deceived by the false messiah?
Soon there will be a WW3 there will be a man the antichrist who will rise up and bring peace. He will claim to be god but in fact is satan. He will make you receive a chip and also you must bow down to worship him. Then after in the midst of the koss God and his people will reign down from the Heavens. All the people who worshiped the beast(antichrist/false messiah) will be condemned for all eternity. This is in the book of Revelation in the Bible.Jews and Muslims will you be deceived by the false messiah?
People will wish for mountains to fall on them in shame when they see they have been deceived by anti christ.Jews and Muslims will you be deceived by the false messiah?
answer: You don't seem to realize that Jews and Muslims don't have ';Revelation'; in their sacred books and they aren't Christian. Therefore they don't believe the rantings of someone railing away at Rome in vague metaphor and rewritings of Daniel.
Perhaps if you studied what Jews actually think about their coming Messiah you'd realize they don't believe the same about messiahs that you do. Theirs won't be divine, won't walk on water, won't be worshiped and won't need a second or third time to accomplish things.
# # #
Your arrogance doesn't do your religion well.
Your bible is NOT the Jewish Tanakh and some of us non-Christians are more educated than most Christians apparently. There are NOT 500 prophecies on the Messiah. There are a small number of them and Jesus fulfilled NONE of them.
* The Sanhedrin will be re-established (Isaiah 1:26)
* Once he is King, leaders of other nations will look to him for guidance. (Isaiah 2:4)
* The whole world will worship the One God of Israel (Isaiah 2:17)
* He will be descended from King David (Isaiah 11:1) via King Solomon (1 Chron. 22:8-10)
* The Moshiach will be a man of this world, an observant Jew with ';fear of God'; (Isaiah 11:2)
*****In other words - this must all be accomplished in a human lifetime*****
* Evil and tyranny will not be able to stand before his leadership (Isaiah 11:4)
* Knowledge of God will fill the world (Isaiah 11:9)
* He will include and attract people from all cultures and nations (Isaiah 11:10)
* All Israelites will be returned to their homeland (Isaiah 11:12)
* Death will be swallowed up forever (Isaiah 25:8)
* There will be no more hunger or illness, and death will cease (Isaiah 25:8)
* All of the dead will rise again (Isaiah 26:19)
* The Jewish people will experience eternal joy and gladness (Isaiah 51:11)
* He will be a messenger of peace (Isaiah 52:7)
* Nations will end up recognizing the wrongs they did to Israel (Isaiah 52:13-53:5)
* The peoples of the world will turn to the Jews for spiritual guidance (Zechariah 8:23)
* The ruined cities of Israel will be restored (Ezekiel 16:55)
* Weapons of war will be destroyed (Ezekiel 39:9)
* The Temple will be rebuilt (Ezekiel 40) resuming many of the suspended mitzvot
* He will then perfect the entire world to serve God together (Zephaniah 3:9)
* Jews will know the Torah without Study (Jeremiah 31:33)
* He will give you all the desires of your heart (Psalms 37:4)
* He will take the barren land and make it abundant and fruitful (Isaiah 51:3, Amos 9:13-15, Ezekiel 36:29-30, Isaiah 11:6-9).
Thanks to Mark S and Plushy Bear
# # #
K - have you read the BofM, the Koran, the Eddas, the Vedics, the Tanakh or the Satanic Bible?
I have and several versions of the bible.
No, I will not be deceived by the false messiah (whatever that's supposed to be) because I'm Jewish and therefore too smart to be deceived by anyone including Satan, the anti-Christ or any of those other so-called deceivers. Nobody deceives me and gets away with it! Quick to judge???? We've been around for 5,000 years and we are too quick to judge? Another example of an arrogant Christian that for some reason won't leave the Jews alone. I'm sure a Muslim would answer in the same way.
According to revelations, shouldn't your question read, ';Jews, Muslims, Most Christians, and Everyone Else...?'; That's the deal isn't it, WE'RE ALL going to be decieved, except the select few. I'll tell you what, you worry about how you're going to tell the anti-christ from the real christ, and I'll worry about who I believe will be the messiach, kay?
Did you really expect a Jew or a Muslim to say yes i will be deceived.
You can not convince anybody apart from the working of God.
And btw all these secular people who get high and holy don't even read their holy books and they think they know more than you and I put together.
We (Jews) are the ones who HAVEN'T been decieved by false messiahs. Clearly, you have. But we are quite adept at interpreting our own text and prphecy, which is why I can give you an unhesitant 'no, we will not'.
BTW, quoting your own religious text to people who think of it as nothing more than any other novel, isnt a very good tactic.
You have a jesis, he's your false messiah.
Dont try to tell us we read our books, our prophecies, wrong. You've been decieved, I can read hebrew and I can read torah and I can tell you, you've been decieved. Does your religion teach you to be rude like you are? mine does not.
we think the opposite.Because you are waiting an incarnation of God and anti christ will come and show fake miracles .it is the only way for someone follow a maniac.we are a waiting a simple man so this man should have a good ethic for we can follow him.
Christians were already deceived by a messiah, for everyone else to have a fear of a wrong messiah is certainly possible also.
Jews do not believe in any 'messiah'.They do not even worship Messiah(Jesus Christ).
I stopped reading at ';bow down to worship him';...we don't worship men, we bow only to God.
Obviously we Jews won't be - after all, we weren't fooled by the claims that Jesus was our maschiach. We knew he was a false messiah, he didn't fulfill the prophecies.
So, cheers for your concern, but we have the Tanakh, and its specific details on how to know our messiah. Oh, and the TINY matter of him bringing *world peace* BEFORE he dies might offer us a bit of a clue........ *voice dripping with sarcasm*
EDIT TO ASKER
We are not 'judging'. We are exercising our RIGHT to DISAGREE with you. You asked us - we've answered. Deal with it.
FRAU ASHER - well said!
People will wish for mountains to fall on them in shame when they see they have been deceived by anti christ.Jews and Muslims will you be deceived by the false messiah?
answer: You don't seem to realize that Jews and Muslims don't have ';Revelation'; in their sacred books and they aren't Christian. Therefore they don't believe the rantings of someone railing away at Rome in vague metaphor and rewritings of Daniel.
Perhaps if you studied what Jews actually think about their coming Messiah you'd realize they don't believe the same about messiahs that you do. Theirs won't be divine, won't walk on water, won't be worshiped and won't need a second or third time to accomplish things.
# # #
Your arrogance doesn't do your religion well.
Your bible is NOT the Jewish Tanakh and some of us non-Christians are more educated than most Christians apparently. There are NOT 500 prophecies on the Messiah. There are a small number of them and Jesus fulfilled NONE of them.
* The Sanhedrin will be re-established (Isaiah 1:26)
* Once he is King, leaders of other nations will look to him for guidance. (Isaiah 2:4)
* The whole world will worship the One God of Israel (Isaiah 2:17)
* He will be descended from King David (Isaiah 11:1) via King Solomon (1 Chron. 22:8-10)
* The Moshiach will be a man of this world, an observant Jew with ';fear of God'; (Isaiah 11:2)
*****In other words - this must all be accomplished in a human lifetime*****
* Evil and tyranny will not be able to stand before his leadership (Isaiah 11:4)
* Knowledge of God will fill the world (Isaiah 11:9)
* He will include and attract people from all cultures and nations (Isaiah 11:10)
* All Israelites will be returned to their homeland (Isaiah 11:12)
* Death will be swallowed up forever (Isaiah 25:8)
* There will be no more hunger or illness, and death will cease (Isaiah 25:8)
* All of the dead will rise again (Isaiah 26:19)
* The Jewish people will experience eternal joy and gladness (Isaiah 51:11)
* He will be a messenger of peace (Isaiah 52:7)
* Nations will end up recognizing the wrongs they did to Israel (Isaiah 52:13-53:5)
* The peoples of the world will turn to the Jews for spiritual guidance (Zechariah 8:23)
* The ruined cities of Israel will be restored (Ezekiel 16:55)
* Weapons of war will be destroyed (Ezekiel 39:9)
* The Temple will be rebuilt (Ezekiel 40) resuming many of the suspended mitzvot
* He will then perfect the entire world to serve God together (Zephaniah 3:9)
* Jews will know the Torah without Study (Jeremiah 31:33)
* He will give you all the desires of your heart (Psalms 37:4)
* He will take the barren land and make it abundant and fruitful (Isaiah 51:3, Amos 9:13-15, Ezekiel 36:29-30, Isaiah 11:6-9).
Thanks to Mark S and Plushy Bear
# # #
K - have you read the BofM, the Koran, the Eddas, the Vedics, the Tanakh or the Satanic Bible?
I have and several versions of the bible.
No, I will not be deceived by the false messiah (whatever that's supposed to be) because I'm Jewish and therefore too smart to be deceived by anyone including Satan, the anti-Christ or any of those other so-called deceivers. Nobody deceives me and gets away with it! Quick to judge???? We've been around for 5,000 years and we are too quick to judge? Another example of an arrogant Christian that for some reason won't leave the Jews alone. I'm sure a Muslim would answer in the same way.
According to revelations, shouldn't your question read, ';Jews, Muslims, Most Christians, and Everyone Else...?'; That's the deal isn't it, WE'RE ALL going to be decieved, except the select few. I'll tell you what, you worry about how you're going to tell the anti-christ from the real christ, and I'll worry about who I believe will be the messiach, kay?
Did you really expect a Jew or a Muslim to say yes i will be deceived.
You can not convince anybody apart from the working of God.
And btw all these secular people who get high and holy don't even read their holy books and they think they know more than you and I put together.
We (Jews) are the ones who HAVEN'T been decieved by false messiahs. Clearly, you have. But we are quite adept at interpreting our own text and prphecy, which is why I can give you an unhesitant 'no, we will not'.
BTW, quoting your own religious text to people who think of it as nothing more than any other novel, isnt a very good tactic.
You have a jesis, he's your false messiah.
Dont try to tell us we read our books, our prophecies, wrong. You've been decieved, I can read hebrew and I can read torah and I can tell you, you've been decieved. Does your religion teach you to be rude like you are? mine does not.
we think the opposite.Because you are waiting an incarnation of God and anti christ will come and show fake miracles .it is the only way for someone follow a maniac.we are a waiting a simple man so this man should have a good ethic for we can follow him.
Christians were already deceived by a messiah, for everyone else to have a fear of a wrong messiah is certainly possible also.
Jews do not believe in any 'messiah'.They do not even worship Messiah(Jesus Christ).
I stopped reading at ';bow down to worship him';...we don't worship men, we bow only to God.
Obviously we Jews won't be - after all, we weren't fooled by the claims that Jesus was our maschiach. We knew he was a false messiah, he didn't fulfill the prophecies.
So, cheers for your concern, but we have the Tanakh, and its specific details on how to know our messiah. Oh, and the TINY matter of him bringing *world peace* BEFORE he dies might offer us a bit of a clue........ *voice dripping with sarcasm*
EDIT TO ASKER
We are not 'judging'. We are exercising our RIGHT to DISAGREE with you. You asked us - we've answered. Deal with it.
FRAU ASHER - well said!
The best way to know who is on the side of Good is to see who will NOT join the False Messiah (antichrist) ?
The False Messiah will become the Leader of Israel.
He will be the most Evil and DECEPTIVE leader in the history of Mankind.
He will unite the entire world against the Monotheistic religion which is the greatest threat to his evil and deception.
If you identify which nation the False Messiah will rule from then you will then realize which people are on the side of Good.
Good will be called Evil and Evil will be called Good.
.The best way to know who is on the side of Good is to see who will NOT join the False Messiah (antichrist) ?
And what most of these Xians have missed is that the Anti-Christ's Armies of Darkness will go forth, Singing, ';Onward Christian Soldiers';, and waiving flags bearing the Cross, as they march off on a New Crusade, there to subjugate, kill and destroy, in the name of the their new leader.The best way to know who is on the side of Good is to see who will NOT join the False Messiah (antichrist) ?
Is there a question in there?
Pleaze let us all know who that is, when you figure it out.
I'll be looking out for the Sith Lord, ok?
We are now in an age where evil is called good, and the nations rising up against the Jews over the status of Jerusalem
(see Zechariah 12-14)
The faithful of Israel are under attack from the nations and anti-Jewish Jews.
forsho
He will be the most Evil and DECEPTIVE leader in the history of Mankind.
He will unite the entire world against the Monotheistic religion which is the greatest threat to his evil and deception.
If you identify which nation the False Messiah will rule from then you will then realize which people are on the side of Good.
Good will be called Evil and Evil will be called Good.
.The best way to know who is on the side of Good is to see who will NOT join the False Messiah (antichrist) ?
And what most of these Xians have missed is that the Anti-Christ's Armies of Darkness will go forth, Singing, ';Onward Christian Soldiers';, and waiving flags bearing the Cross, as they march off on a New Crusade, there to subjugate, kill and destroy, in the name of the their new leader.The best way to know who is on the side of Good is to see who will NOT join the False Messiah (antichrist) ?
Is there a question in there?
Pleaze let us all know who that is, when you figure it out.
I'll be looking out for the Sith Lord, ok?
We are now in an age where evil is called good, and the nations rising up against the Jews over the status of Jerusalem
(see Zechariah 12-14)
The faithful of Israel are under attack from the nations and anti-Jewish Jews.
forsho
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)